This discussion has been closed.
Posted by billyblob (U14390155) on Tuesday, 17th May 2011
Hi All,
Sorry if this thread has already been covered on the board . I planted onions/garlic and shallots in October and they have done quite well despite the big freeze/drought. The million dollar question is when do I harvest? I have already pulled one flower spike off the onions.
Thanks in advance.
Bill
, in reply to message 1.
Posted by CaptainZucchini (U14832117) on Wednesday, 18th May 2011
For overwintering onion the recommendation is to stat picking them as needed, as soon as they are large enough; they tend not to store well. Harvest your garlic and shallots when the leaves turn yellow; lay the bulbs in a dry and airy place until they are 'rustling' dry, and then store.
I planted Garlic ' Marco ' on September 25th , it is yellowing already and it has had plenty of water. I lifted one at the weekend and I was a bit disappointed in the size ; perfectly usable but not a prize winner, to be fair I garden in Edinburgh not the Isle of Wight. I must say the flower spikes are tasty . I've had them in a stir-fry and in salads.
I planted garlic last year September/October time. It's looking good above ground but the anticipated bulging prize winning bulbs just peeping above the furface haven't materialised yet.
Wish they'd get a move on, I had visions of a long string of platted garlic hanging in the kitchen by now so it would be intresting to know when they can be harvested. We've had enough rain these past few weeks to flood the sahara so they've had plenty of water.
I think mine need to be lifted in the next couple of weeks . I am told that Garlic acclimatises to local conditions, I intend to save the biggest cloves to plant in the Autumn . I do think if you live in areas where conditions are less than ideal, it is better to plant in Autumn than in early Spring.
Mine where planted last autumn but they have still to show any tendency to to start die down.
Your garlic is still growing by the sound of it , I am no expert on growing garlic or anything for that matter, however since I got my allotment 14 years ago I have found some gardening writers that give sage advice, first amongst these is Joy Larkom .
Definitely leave the garlic until the leaves start to wither for the biggest bulbs. And then follow the advice given about saving the largest cloves to plant next autumn. I've been doing this for 10 years or more and now get huge garlic, from wet, heavy, Herefordshire soil, so I do really think they have acclimatised themselves.
Off the subject slightly, but my Bangladeshi friend was horrified that I was going to dispose of the central spike. She said it mades lovely 'chutney', that lovely one with fresh tomato and sliced onion.
I've tried it and it is very nice, the sliced spikes are a little more delicate than onion rings. Waste not...
Lottie
I have given up trying to grow Allium from cloves.
I bought some bulbs last year. they have all done well but, if my Garlic efforts are anything to go by, I have got to do "Bulbil" growing in future not growing on of clove segments.
In deed all these garden bulbs may be dealt with in that way, daffodils, tulips, begonia, Allium the lot and I am beginning to think that without growing them that way one's knowledge and growing skill is seriously limited, by others intent on making the real profit from garden/ horticultural soil.
Tulips take up to ten years but if i am planting a Fruit tree fro perhaps a 100 years or 130 why should I not plant "bulbils" and seeds for 10?? Is there something clever about cloves, and sets?
I have given up trying to grow Allium from cloves.
I bought some bulbs last year. they have all done well but, if my Garlic efforts are anything to go by, I have got to do "Bulbil" growing in future not the growing on of clove segments.
In deed all these garden bulbs may be dealt with in that way, daffodils, tulips, begonia, Allium, the lot, and I am beginning to think that, without growing them that way, one's knowledge and growing skill is seriously limited, by others intent on making the real profit from garden/ horticultural soil.
Tulips take up to ten years but if i am planting a Fruit tree fro perhaps a 100 years or 130 why should I not plant "bulbils" and seeds for 10?? Is there something clever about cloves, and sets?
Onions 2 years
Garlic 2 years
Daffodils 3-5 years
Begonia probably five years.
If you look up Life Cycle of theAllium on Google you will find a vast amount of information about the different species.
There are 600 in the genus. I have got 4 very pretty ones indeed.
I think i know what two of them are. The Allium Sativa and the Allium Mt Everest.
I have very pretty small ones as well,red and blue. Names elude me, but i shall take a picture and search for them.
I currently have the seed heads, after the flower on all four so I am thinking what I shall do with the seeds when they seem to be ripe.
Somebody suggested replanting the seeds straight away, but I am not sure about that.
The meaning of the word "scape" eludes me for the moment.
Dashing out and buying more Bulbs to augment the crop is not the answer, although a few more species to get on with would be interesting.
My onion seed species, which I planted in a rows, like Monty said, are doing ok. following them will give me a clearer idea of how to proceed with all the others.
Allium seed packets will be bought.
Also somebody suggested "modules". Are modules the things which come in hundreds and are about 1cm square?
How does one plant seed in modules since the seed is so small any way.
my Optivisor would not be sufficient magnification to be accurate; or would it?
Would I bring Allium seed on better by using modules in the GH, at this time of year, or just plant in rows outside carefully? I would not want to waste seed!
Welcome to the new Gardening Board. If this is your first time, then make sure you check out the
or  to take part in a discussion.
The message board is currently closed for posting.
Weekdays 09:00-00:00
Weekends 10:00-00:00
This messageboard is .
Find out more about this board's
Â鶹¹ÙÍøÊ×Ò³Èë¿Ú © 2014 The Â鶹¹ÙÍøÊ×Ò³Èë¿Ú is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.
This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.