Eight of the best time travel movies
Does the science in the time travel movies that we love actually make sense?
As Back to the Future, arguably the greatest time travel movie in history, turns 40, 麻豆官网首页入口 Radio 4's Screenshot is whizzing back through the decades to revisit some of the best era-hopping adventures ever made.
Time travel movies cover many genres, from action-adventure, like Back to the Future and Avengers: Endgame, to romantic-comedy, like Groundhog Day. But however you choose to tell your story, you're going to run into some complicated logic, as this episode's guests explain.
So, join Mark Kermode and Ellen E Jones as they hop in a DeLorean to relive some the most memorable time travel movies of all time, and find out how much of the brain-scrambling science involved actually makes sense…
Back to the Future
There were time travel movies before Back to the Future came out in 1985 – an adaptation of HG Wells’ The Time Machine won an Oscar in 1960 – but Robert Zemeckis’ classic heralded a golden era for the genre. It’s the story of Marty (Michael J Fox), a teenager who accidentally goes back in time and nearly ruins his own present.
Professor Sean Carroll, a theoretical physicist at John Hopkins University, who knows a thing or two about time travel science, says: “Back to the Future is amazing. It’s a lot of fun. As time travel, it makes absolutely no sense at all.” It all comes down to that family photograph, in which siblings begin to fade from existence as Marty changes history. “Why does the photograph start to fade at that moment in time?” asks Carroll. It may not be logical, but does that make the film anything less than brilliant? Absolutely not.
Looper
Rian Johnson is one of the greats when it comes to cinematic puzzles. In his Knives Out movies, he constructed knotty murder mysteries that confounded all but the most perceptive sleuths. In the 2012 movie Looper, he turns his incredible mind to time travel, for a story about an assassin who’s ordered to murder his future self.
“It uses time travel as a device to explore big themes of free will and fate,” says Mark. It’s a complicated time logic, but Johnson treats it lightly and, as Kermode says, keeps the plot moving so quickly “it never… allows the audience to go, ‘Hang on a minute.’” As Johnson says, science shouldn’t always be the focus. “It’s about making sure the story logic makes sense in a way that the audience will stick with you,” he says. “That’s much more important than whether the flowchart makes sense.”
Listen to Rian Johnson talking about his Knives Out movies in this episode of Screenshot
Avengers: Endgame
In the 2019 blockbuster Avengers: Endgame, Iron Man and his team of superheroes have to travel back in time to find infinity stones, which will allow them to defeat supervillain Thanos and save the world.
The filmmakers brought on Professor Sean Carroll to advise them on how to make it as ‘accurate’ as possible. “I explained that the safest thing, by far, to do is to travel back to the past but never change things in a way that would be noticeable,” he says. “So it’s mostly consistent.”
Radio 1's Ali Plumb meets the cast of Avengers: Endgame
Superman
Professor Carroll says there is the tiniest grain of scientific truth in the time travel in the 1978 Superman. At the end of Richard Donner’s classic, Superman fails to save Lois from a horrible accident. Distraught, he flies around Earth so fast that it spins in the opposite direction, reversing time, allowing him another chance to rescue his love.
“There’s the slightest wisp of inspiration for that from real physics,” says Carroll. “When objects in the astrophysical universe are rotated fast enough in the right way… you can possibly go backwards in time.”
12 Monkeys
In Terry Gilliam’s 1995 film, a prisoner (Bruce Willis) is sent back in time to try to prevent a deadly virus from destroying the world.
While some time travel movies obsess over the scientific detail, 12 Monkeys does not. Gilliam is much more interested in the madness of the idea than the technicalities. And Mark Kermode enjoys that. “Bruce Willis is sent back to the past by being stuck in a plastic tube,” he says. “And that’s it. Okay, fine.”
Watch 12 Monkeys on 麻豆官网首页入口 iPlayer
Groundhog Day
Not all time travel movies are about building a machine. Sometimes it’s all about an inexplicable time loop, what Ellen calls “the most emotionally resonant sub-genre of time travel fiction”.
A time loop is when one or more people experience the same timeframe over and over again. In 1993’s Groundhog Day, that’s Bill Murray as a cantankerous news reporter who keeps living the same day, and keeps trying to seduce his producer (Andie MacDowell). Critic Anne Billson says: “What he learns, by repetition, is to be a nice person. He gets the girl because he’s a nice person. But basically he’s a nice person because he’s tried everything else and it hasn’t worked.”
Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure
It may be one of the sillier titles in this list, but this 1989 cult comedy has one of the most sensible approaches to time travel. Bill and Ted (Alex Winter and Keanu Reeves) travel back in time in order to pass history class and (eventually) save the world.
“The problem with movies about time travel is once you have a time machine, there’s no pressure,” says Professor Carroll. “You can’t be in a hurry. You have a time machine! Bill and Ted used that for comedic effect.” Most excellently, they take time travel in their leisurely stride.
Interstellar
“I think it’s super-duper accurate,” says Professor Carroll of Christopher Nolan’s 2014 sci-fi epic, about a group of scientists who travel through a wormhole in search of a new planet for humanity. “When there are wormholes, and there’s a black hole, and there’s motion near the speed of light – all that was absolutely super-duper rigorously figured out.”
So if you want to watch something that shows potentially possible time travel, this is it. Until the last scene with books being pushed from across time and space. “Then Christopher Nolan just let his imagination go a little far,” says Professor Carroll.
Find out more about Mark and Ellen's journey through time travel in movies, and on TV, by listening to the episode in full on 麻豆官网首页入口 Sounds.
More articles from Screenshot
-
Seven TV shows and films that changed the world
Fictional depictions that changed people's minds in the real world.
-
Eight of the most memorable pop star portrayals on screen
The pop idol stories that struck a chord with us in film and on TV.
-
Eight of the most memorable depictions of Las Vegas in film
Ellen and Mark explore gritty and glamorous portrayals of the city that never sleeps.
-
Eight of the greatest prison movies and TV shows
Ellen and Mark go behind bars to praise the best depictions of prison life.