Main content

Today Puzzle #653

Puzzle No. 653 – Tuesday 14 January

There is a 50 pound note in 1 of every 100 envelopes. Your friend has made a machine which can detect the valuable envelopes with 99% accuracy and offers it to you for 30 pounds. Should you purchase it to help you choose one envelope?

Today’s #PuzzleForToday has been set by Dr Shaun Fitzgerald, Director of The Royal Institution

Click here for the answer

The machine will select 99% of the valuable envelopes, which comprise 1% of the total. Unfortunately, the machine will also select 1% of the empty ones, which comprise 99% of the total. The expected value using the machine is therefore £50 x (99% x 1%) / (99% x 1% + 1% x 99%) = £25. This is lower than the price of the selecting machine which would therefore not be deemed to be a sensible purchase. You would be better off choosing an envelope without purchasing the machine as the expected value of that is 1% x £50 = 50p.

More fiendish brain-teasers and quizzes on Â鶹¹ÙÍøÊ×Ò³Èë¿Ú Radio...